Top 10 car alarm systems
Criteria for choosing the best alarm for the car
Buy the best car alarm, making a choice of hundreds of models offered, it is very difficult. What you need to pay attention to? Let's try to understand the variety of terms that are filled with advertising leaflets.
- Principle of validation - the way in which the alarm determines the legality of access to the car. In the most advanced models, in addition to the radio commands from the key fob, use is made to check whether the owner has a radio tag or enter a PIN code with the help of standard car buttons.
- Type of radio protocol. Presently protected from intellectual hacking (use of code grabber) is considered only interactive codewhile outdated alarms only work to receive a single command from the key fob and do not request authentication. The 433 MHz radio keychains are gradually replacing high-frequency systems of the 868 MHz and 2.4 GHz bands, making common code grabbers useless physically by changing the frequency and width of the band.
- Telematics support. Modern manufacturers of security systems provide their customers with full-fledged car position tracking services using GSM-network and satellite-based capabilities. The ability to control the status of the alarm in any place where there is coverage of the cellular network, and to receive information from it, eliminates the main drawback of alarms - the limited range of direct communication with the key fob.
- Remote engine start. A fairly popular option, but with a large number of restrictions: the inability to remotely start outside the radio reception zone (this problem is eliminated in telematic alarms), extremely low efficiency on diesel vehicles (working at idle, the diesel engine warms up very slowly).
- Availability / Supported Type. In order to reduce the cost, a number of alarms use low-current positioning based on a signal from base stations of a cellular network (LBS), and to work with satellite systems, an additional module must be connected.
- Support integration intoCAN (LIN) bus First of all, it is necessary to create complex security systems where an analog connection is difficult or impossible (for example, if the activation of a regular central lock requires a preliminary waking up of the protection and switching unit of the onboard electrical wiring). If the functionality needed by the client can be achieved by analog connections, a qualified installer will avoid this. Thus, overpayment for the presence of a digital interface is not always justified.
- The number of zones of protection (or, in other words, the number of possible causes of an alarm). In addition to the standard set of "opening the doors / hood / trunk-ignition on-a sharp blow," for the modern alarm must have at least the presence of a tilt / rolling sensor, which is implemented by warning about jacking or towing a car.
Top 10 best car alarms of 2017-2018
Category | A place | Name | Rating | Price |
---|---|---|---|---|
Best cheap car alarms | 1 | TOMAHAWK 9.9 | 8.8 / 10 | 4 800 |
2 | KGB EX-7 DIALOG | 8.6 / 10 | 3 500 | |
3 | Sheriff ZX-750 PRO | 8.3 / 10 | 3 900 | |
The best two-way alarms and security systems | 1 | Pandora DX 90BT | 9.8 / 10 | 16 500 |
2 | StarLine E66 2CAN + 2LIN ECO | 9.6 / 10 | 7 750 | |
3 | Pandora DXL 3945 | 9.5 / 10 | 29 060 | |
4 | Starline a63 | 9.3 / 10 | 6 750 | |
The best telematic car alarm | 1 | Ghost-840 | 9.4 / 10 | 21 750 |
2 | Pandect X-1900 BT | 9.2 / 10 | 23 310 | |
3 | StarLine M96 L | 9.0 / 10 | 23 500 | |
4 | Pandect X-1100 | 8.8 / 10 | 12 300 |
Best cheap car alarms
TOMAHAWK 9.9
4 800
Against the backdrop of modern security systems, the Tomahawk already looks archaic - a simple keychain, remote, rather than built-in, a manual shock sensor, the same simple siren-horn in the kit. However, if finances are just barely enough, and you don’t want to buy frank slag, which even a schoolboy will open with a code grabber, then Tomahawk 9.9 alarm system will be a good choice for buying.
As in previous versions of "Indian axes", here we use the interactive code, and even at a frequency of 868 MHz. The functionality of the alarm itself is standard for this class, and it makes no sense to describe it additionally. But there is a nice bonus in the form of support for autorun - of course, without any keyless immobilizer bypasses and flexibly customizable service functions, but the alarm costs, respectively. For vehicles that are signaled in this price range, this functionality is quite enough. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
8.8 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Good inexpensive car alarm. All you need is able, why is something more on the “top ten”? |
KGB EX-7 DIALOG
3 500
The advantages of the “younger” KGB system series include the presence of a dialogue code, which, although implemented in the 433 MHz overloaded radio band, but still using a narrow-band transceiver, so there is reason to believe that you will not have to recall the algorithm convulsively at Auchan. manual shutdown of the alarm at the alarm, stubbornly refusing to accept commands from the key fob. And by itself, a compact radio module with a two-shoulder antenna somehow reminds the old “Pandora”, to be honest.
Otherwise, we again have the most usual alarm system that supports, nevertheless, the connection of an optional CAN-module and even a GSM / GPS interface. True, if in more “adult” KGB models the CAN module is inserted directly into the slot of the central unit, here everything is the old way - a flat cable from the external unit into the connector. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
8.6 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Keychain is not very convenient, and so for the budget alarm is good. And certainly no worse than "Sherkhanov", which in car dealerships put at a price of exorbitant prices. |
Sheriff ZX-750 PRO
3 900
Traditionally simple alarm system, in the general contours of the key fob of which the outlines of the “Starlines” of old generations are clearly guessed. In other, unlike the same "Cenmax", which StarLine alarms copied up to the colors of the wiring in the connectors, Sheriff looks more like a construction, and the support of the dialogue code and the optional wireless lockout relay allow speaking about this system as anti-theft.
Of course, it is worthwhile to advise this model only under very strict financial constraints. The matter here is far not only in the minimal functionality, but even in the banal inconvenience of setting the shock sensor - it has only one regulator for overall sensitivity, you cannot set the warning and alarm levels separately. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
8.3 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Put it on the "tag", takes the range normally, not buggy. For the money, in short. |
The best two-way alarms and security systems
Pandora DX 90BT
16 500
For a long time, “AlarmTreyd” did not have a model with normal “minced meat” and an acceptable price - in the catalog there were either frankly trimmed models or monsters like DXL 4970 with a price of almost 50 thousand. Therefore, the appearance of the DX 90 BT is a serious step in the promotion on the market, which the update of the StarLine model range seriously turned against the Pandora / Pandect systems.
So what can this security system? In addition to the 868-megahertz key fob (by the way, with an OLED display, which is very convenient in bright sunshine), the owner's smartphone can be used to control, not via the usual GSM channel, but using Bluetooth. Thus, in normal operation (“disarm / start the engine”) you can not spend money on the Internet traffic of the SIM card installed in the alarm system, and do without the delays that are inevitable when working with the GSM channel. Via Bluetooth, the bundled radio relay works. The alarm allows the engine to start automatically, and for this most vehicles will not need to install any standard immobilizer crawlers: the IMMO-KEY port on the signaling system can emulate a command to allow the launch, including on vehicles with a dynamic immobilizer code. Key cloning is carried out when setting up an alarm using the Pandora CLONE proprietary service. The Slave mode is also supported, and with a flexible choice of secondary validation method: a pin code on the vehicle’s standard buttons worn by a radio tag (also working via Bluetooth). Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.8 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Very interesting security system. The key chain, by the way, can not be worn with me at all - I open it with a regular key or smart, in my pocket with a radio tag. |
StarLine E66 2CAN + 2LIN ECO
7 750
The novelty from StarLine, undoubtedly, deserves the closest attention. Judge for yourself: with the recommended price of less than 8,000 rubles, we are offered a good security system of the latest sixth generation, which has full support for working with CAN and LIN wiring (so that the owners of Lad are not cheated). Moreover, the capabilities of the sixth generation include indirect blocking of the engine start on a digital bus, and “smart” bypass of the standard immobilizer without any additional trackers.
Of course, in the out-of-the-box state, the E66 does not have a power startup module, as indicated by the first six in the label. But thanks to the modular platform, nothing will prevent you from subsequently complementing an already installed system with autorun or installing a telematics module - it often happens that car owners initially want to save on the signaling price, and then think about expanding its functionality. And the E66 makes it easy. The telematic module, by the way, doesn’t really hurt the alarm: in the current third edition of the signaling protocol, StarLine learned to read and transmit to the user not only the information needed by the alarm itself, but also the injection computer controller errors: thus, your smartphone with the installed application will also become a free diagnostic tool entry-level device. In urban conditions, it is also important that the alarm system operates at a frequency of 868 MHz - this frequency range is loaded much less than the usual 433 MHz, and in combination with a narrow-band transceiver, we get trouble-free radio channel operation even at hypermarked parking lots. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.6 / 10
Rating
Reviews
For the money it is the best car alarm, I did not even doubt the purchase. 8 thousand for the alarm of this level now - a great offer! |
29 060
A full-fledged security complex, which allows the most flexible implementation of vehicle protection while maintaining ease of operation: the user can use both the remote control and the vehicle’s regular radio key, while starting the engine will be impossible without his secretly wearing radio tag. A full range of telematics services is also supported (mobile apps are available only for iOS and Android). The alarm kit includes an autorun relay module, which makes it possible to start the engine both when connected via a digital bus and when there is a need for power management of ignition and electric starter. Implementing a complete protection for the installer is helped by the possibility of pairing car alarms with the engine compartment module and the lockout radio relay, but acquiring them will increase the already high enough signaling price. But, since such alarms are intended primarily to protect business and premium cars, this does not significantly affect the total amount of work, given the complexity of the installation and the corresponding price level for installers. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.5 / 10
Rating
Reviews
This is the best car alarm, it is extremely convenient that the autorun is easily controlled through a mobile application, while I’m calm for the safety of the car - in the absence of a wearable tag it is impossible to leave on it. |
6 750
This model of car alarm replaced the outdated A61, having received an updated modular platform StarLine. It was the modularity that became its main advantage - although in the basic version the alarm has a rather limited functionality, but at the same time it has a minimum price, and the buyer can choose all the necessary modules without overpaying for functions that he does not need. "Out of the box" StarLine A63 boasts the presence of modern cryptographic signal coding, an ergonomic keyring with a fairly good connection in urban environments, flexible programmable channels for the implementation of auxiliary service functions (folding mirrors, finishing windows and so on). It is possible to implement the Slave mode, in which the removal and arming of the system is carried out with a regular car key, and the radio key fob functions as a wearable tag validator. Significantly expand the functionality of the alarm allows installation of additional expansion modules on its board:
Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.3 / 10
Rating
Reviews
By today's standards, this car alarm is already considered a cheap model, but it is one of the best. I can not say anything (pah-pah) about resistance to theft, but at least there are no problems with it exactly. |
The best telematic car alarm
Ghost-840
21 750
The current flagship of the "800th" series got all the functionality that now befits this class.The system can be controlled both through a mobile application and from a regular car key - the owner can use wearable radio tags with a dialogue code or enter a PIN code on the vehicle’s standard buttons to confirm access rights.
The pLine-221 ultra-compact blocking relay can be detected in the alarm box - this module does not require any wiring to connect to the central unit, so the installer can install it anywhere, and the dimensions will allow us to weave it even directly into the wiring harness. Communication with the central unit is not over the radio channel, but directly over the + 12V power wire: it will not be possible to drown the air with interference, as it would have been with the radio relay. In addition, it has its own accelerometer built in: even if the hijacker removes the alarm itself, at the start of the movement the lock will work independently. And, of course, the system supports autostart of the engine with a “smart” immobilizer bypass, while the previous “Ghosts” required external track workers. The only "but" is that if your car does not support autostart directly on the CAN bus, you will have to purchase the ESM-250 power module. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.4 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Serious system. In addition, immediately bought the engine compartment module and check-control: the machine is more secure, and all diagnostics are in the mobile application right away. |
Pandect X-1900 BT
23 310
The novelty in the “Pandektov” line has come out quite controversial, and giving it high points in the rating of the best car alarm systems does not give a price: this microsystem falls into the segment of top players, that is, initially limited to the number of potential buyers. Of course, out of the box there is also a keyless immobilizer bypass, GPS / GLONASS, and Bluetooth authorization from wireless tags, a Pandora smart watch or a smartphone, but for example, you will not connect an external satellite dish to this alarm, so The reception quality of the satellite signal will very seriously depend on the installation method.
Like other Pandect microsystems, the novelty will be of interest first of all to those who have the possibilities for competent installation of the central unit seriously limited by the layout - here the small size of the central unit gives its advantages. But if there is enough space, then, perhaps, the StarLine system, similar in capabilities, will cost you less. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.2 / 10
Rating
Reviews
I chose an alarm without a key fob, demanding good work in Slave-mode and GPS support. We advised this, I do not regret. |
StarLine M96 L
23 500
* Even at the time of the announcement of the sixth-generation systems, the M96 stood out as if by itself - unlike the other Starlines, where the key fob remained a key fob, everything was assigned to a mobile application, and the phone could be connected to alarm and via Bluetooth. Actually, the label itself hints at mixed origins - the letter “M” has traditionally been used by StarLine beacons, while “96” uniquely identifies the sixth generation of alarms with auto start. Now this system is knocked out of the general range even more: given that even fourth-generation alarms with fresh firmware are already capable of keyless immobilizer bypass, the M96 conservatism, which requires an external lineman, looks even strange. Otherwise, this is a typical good telematic signaling, and yes even able to send an SMS with error codes that occur in the injection system to the owner's phone. A serious advantage of the design is the presence of a built-in lithium-ion battery (again the legacy of GPS beacons), which allows it to remain operational even when the hijacker disconnects the battery. If you travel a lot, the presence of a second SIM card slot will also not be superfluous - you will not have to constantly change the "city" and "exit", especially if you consider that with a competent installation of the alarm system, you will have to disassemble the cars. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
9.0 / 10
Rating
Reviews
Starline application, in my opinion, the most convenient. So I chose M96 and, as I believe, did not lose. |
12 300
This security complex uses a modern, though unusual, approach to implementing control: the alarm is disarmed only by a regular radio key of a car or a team from a cell phone, but for validation, two wearable radio tags are used that come with it. This determines the range of possible users: without a car's radio keys, using the Pandect X-1100 becomes quite inconvenient. It is possible to connect additional modules: GPS receiver, autorun module. An important plus Pandect X-1100 is the possibility of interfacing with wireless relay locks, significantly increasing the safety of the car. The telematic functions provided by the manufacturer provide for the notification of the accident to the relatives of the owner. However, unfortunately, it is impossible to name full-fledged telematics in this case: there is no access to data on the routes of the car with visualization on the map, control via the Internet via a computer or mobile application is impossible. This significantly reduces the attractiveness of the Pandect X-1100 as a telematics system. Main advantages:
Minuses:
|
8.8 / 10
Rating
Reviews
First of all, the alarm system is convenient because there is no need to carry a key chain with you, which for me (the car is far from home) is still 90% of the time useless. The alert on the phone will come at least in another area. |
You can paint the advantages and disadvantages of each particular car alarm model for a long time, but it is better to remind the main point once: first of all, the quality of its work, and reliability depend on the work of the installer. It makes no sense to buy a premium alarm system and at the same time save on the services of a master, especially if he has little knowledge of your car model.